Canned Anchovy Fillets (mashed) Substitute for Anchovy Paste: Exact Ratio
Looking for a anchovy paste substitute? Canned Anchovy Fillets (mashed) works as a direct replacement. Use 2 anchovy fillets mashed = 1 tsp anchovy paste in any recipe that calls for anchovy paste. This swap works best for Caesar dressing, pasta sauces, pizza.
Best Substitute
Canned Anchovy Fillets (mashed)
2 anchovy fillets mashed = 1 tsp anchovy paste
The most direct substitute: it is essentially the same product in whole form. Mash with a fork until smooth. Drain excess oil before mashing.
Tips When Replacing Anchovy Paste in Recipes
Anchovy paste dissolves when heated, adding invisible umami depth to sauces and stews. Even people who dislike anchovies often enjoy dishes made with anchovy paste because the fish flavor melts into the background. Start with a small amount and build up.
What Is Anchovy Paste and Why Substitute It?
A concentrated paste made from ground anchovies, salt, and oil, delivering intense umami and briny depth. Anchovy paste is used in Caesar dressing, puttanesca sauce, compound butters, and as a secret flavor enhancer in many savory dishes.
Canned Anchovy Fillets (mashed) is one of 5 alternatives you can use instead of anchovy paste. For a complete list of anchovy paste substitutes with ratios and cooking tips, visit the full anchovy paste substitute page.
What Else Can I Use Instead of Anchovy Paste?
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use canned anchovy fillets (mashed) instead of anchovy paste?
Yes, you can use canned anchovy fillets (mashed) as a substitute for anchovy paste. Use 2 anchovy fillets mashed = 1 tsp anchovy paste. The most direct substitute: it is essentially the same product in whole form. Mash with a fork until smooth. Drain excess oil before mashing.
How much canned anchovy fillets (mashed) equals anchovy paste?
Use 2 anchovy fillets mashed = 1 tsp anchovy paste to replace anchovy paste with canned anchovy fillets (mashed). Works best for Caesar dressing, pasta sauces, pizza.
What is the best substitute for anchovy paste?
Canned Anchovy Fillets (mashed) is a popular substitute for anchovy paste. Use 2 anchovy fillets mashed = 1 tsp anchovy paste for a 1-to-1 replacement. See all 5 alternatives on our anchovy paste substitute page.